Let’s be honest, there are so many new teacher myths going around these days. And the worst part is, many of us don’t even realize they are myths until later…. Much much later!
In this article, we’ll debunk some of the most common myths and provide you with the truth about what to expect as a new teacher.
Did you know all 7 of these were myths?
P.S. If you are a new teacher and want help setting up your classroom, download this Ultimate First Year Teacher Checklist!
Listen to the podcast:
Myth: You have to be perfect from day one.
Let’s be honest, this is a new teacher myth not only society places on us, but we tend to place on ourselves. This is a common myth that can cause a lot of unnecessary stress for first year teachers.
The truth is, no one is perfect and everyone makes mistakes, especially when starting a new job. It’s important to give yourself grace and remember that teaching is a learning process. Seek guidance from experienced teachers, reflect on your lessons, and make adjustments as needed. Don’t be afraid to ask questions, because that’s the best way you will learn!
Your students will appreciate your effort and dedication, even if everything doesn’t go perfectly from day one. So don’t believe this new teacher myth for one second!
Myth: You have to be strict to earn respect.
A common new teacher myth you might hear is “Don’t smile until January.” This is a common misconception among new teachers, but it’s simply not true.
While it’s important to establish boundaries and expectations in the classroom, being overly strict can actually hinder your ability to build positive relationships with your students. Respect is earned through mutual trust and understanding, not fear.
Instead, focus on creating a safe and supportive learning environment, and your students will naturally respect you as their teacher.
Myth: You have to be an expert in every subject.
Another common new teacher is that you have to be an expert to be a good teacher. The truth is, no one is an expert in every subject and it’s okay to ask for help or do some extra research to prepare for a lesson.
Additionally, many schools have resources available such as curriculum guides and lesson plans to help teachers plan and teach their lessons effectively. Don’t let the fear of not knowing everything hold you back from being a great teacher.
Myth: You have to do everything on your own.
As a first year teacher, it’s easy to feel like you have to do everything on your own. However, this is simply not true. There are many resources available to new teachers, including mentorship programs, professional development opportunities, and support from colleagues.
Don’t be afraid to ask for help or guidance when you need it. Remember, teaching is a collaborative profession and everyone benefits when we work together. So don’t let this new teacher myth get in your way of being the teacher you were meant to be.

Myth: You have to sacrifice your personal life.
I’m not sure how many times I have heard this new teacher myth but it’s simply not true. In fact, if I were to be completely transparent with you, I believed this myth myself until year 2.
This is a common myth that can discourage many potential teachers from pursuing a career in education. While teaching can be a demanding job, it’s important to remember that you still have a life outside of the classroom. It’s important to prioritize self-care and make time for hobbies and activities that bring you joy.
Additionally, many schools offer a work-life balance and encourage their teachers to take time off when needed. Don’t let the new teacher myth of sacrificing your personal life hold you back from pursuing your passion for teaching.
Myth: You have to work 24/7.
Again, a new teacher myth I believed myself, this is a common myth that can be discouraging for new teachers. While it’s true that the first few years can be challenging as you adjust to the demands of the job, it doesn’t mean that they have to be horrible.
With the right support, resources, and mindset, you can have a successful and fulfilling experience as a new teacher. Don’t let this myth have you grinding your entire first year. You might just miss making those important memories… like I did!
Myth: Your first couple of years are going to be horrible.
I’m going to say it louder for the people in the back… YOUR FIRST COUPLE YEARS OF TEACHING DOES NOT HAVE TO BE DIFFICULT! Just because other teachers had a hard first couple of years, doesn’t mean you have to. In fact, that’s one of the reason The Present Teacher began. I help new teachers learn from my mistakes so their first couple of years can be the best years of their life!
While it’s true that the first few years can be challenging as you adjust to the demands of the job, it doesn’t mean that they have to be horrible. With the right support, resources, and strategies, you can have a successful and fulfilling experience as a new teacher. You can have an amazing first year of teaching.
In Summary
Overall, there are several new teacher myths that definitely put a damper on being a new teacher. These new teacher myths include:
- You have to be perfect from day one
- You have to be strict to earn respect
- You have to be an expert in every subject
- You have to do everything on your own
- You have to work 24/7
- Your first couple of years are going to be horrible
All in all, there are so many new teacher myths out there that can really get in the way of you making an impact in the education world. Don’t let these myths stop you from being the teacher you were meant to become!
P.S. Don’t forget to download the Free Ultimate First Year Teacher Checklist!